News Categories
Announcement (9) Amy Babinchak (64) Tips (1) SBS 2011 (6) Windows Essentials 2012 (4) Edwin Sarmiento (28) SQL Server (22) SQL Server 2012 (6) SQL Server Clustering (3) SQL Server Disaster Recovery (6) Windows Server 2008 Clustering (1) log shipping (1) Brian Higgins (3) Uncategorized (42) Hyper-V (67) Virtualization (13) Windows 8 (13) Cisco VPN Client (1) Windows Server 2012 (24) Friend of TT (4) Hangout (2) Office365 (4) DNS (8) Jeremy (7) Cliff Galiher (3) Active Directory (12) ClearOS (4) Linux (4) presentations (2) SQL PASS (6) Chris Matthews (4) Printers (2) SharePoint (8) SQL Server Administration (7) Windows PowerShell (3) recovery model (1) sql server databases (1) Dave Shackelford (7) SMB Nation (1) Steve (1) Boon Tee (5) Kevin Royalty (3) Lee Wilbur (2) Philip Elder (10) SMBKitchen Crew (31) Susan Bradley (15) AlwaysOn (1) AlwaysOn Availability Groups (4) readable secondaries (1) row versioning (1) undocumented (1) The Project (2) Webinar (3) Enterprise for SMB Project (9) Security (25) Remote Desktop Connection for Mac (1) Remote Desktop Services (8) Windows Server 2008 (1) Exchange (15) Powershell (6) Microsoft (15) Performance (7) data types (1) Server 2012 (1) monitoring (1) DevTeach (1) SQL Server High Availability and Disaster Recovery (5) Clusters (44) Hyper-V Server 2012 (2) Business Principles (26) Cost of Doing Business (13) DHCP (7) sbs (15) Windows Server (30) SMBKitchen (26) Windows Server 2008 R2 (4) StorageCraft (1) P2V (1) ShadowProtect (6) StorageCraft ShadowProtect (1) VHDs (1) Intel RAID (2) Intel Server System R2208GZ (1) Intel Server Systems (17) RAID (2) SAS (2) SATA (2) Server Hardware (12) Microsoft Licensing (2) OEM (2) System Builder Tips (4) Intel (5) Intel Channel Partner Program (4) Intel Product Support (10) Intel Server Boards (2) Intel Server Manager (2) Cloud (26) IT Solutions (2) On-Premises (20) SMB (9) WIndows Azure (2) StorageSpaces (1) Error (47) Error Fix (35) Intel Desktop Boards (2) Intel SSDs (2) SSD (2) Business Opportunity (17) Data Security (11) Identity Security (7) Information Security (14) Privacy (2) Intel Modular Server (6) Promise (2) Storage Systems (9) Live ID (2) Microsoft ID (4) User Profiles (2) Articles (2) Building Client Relationships (6) DBCC IND (2) DBCC PAGE (2) filtered indexes (2) SQL Server Index Internals (2) training (11) Adobe (3) Internet Street Smart (8) Intel Storage Systems (2) LSI Corp (2) LSI SAS6160 Switch (2) Storage Spaces (7) Firmware Update (2) Product Support (7) Hybrid Cloud Solutions (3) Server Core (2) MAXDOP (1) SharePoint 2013 (1) SharePoint best practices (1) SQL Server Authentication (1) Family (5) Alternatives (1) SBS 2011 Standard (4) Microsoft Small Business Specialist Community (2) Microsoft Surface (2) SBSC (2) Networking (4) Availability Groups (3) CANITPro (1) HA/DR (1) Step-By-Step: Creating a SQL Server 2012 AlwaysOn Availability Group (1) webcast (1) VMWare (2) Conferences (2) Client Focus (2) Disaster Recovery (6) Error Workaround (8) Troubleshooting (4) Logitech (2) Product Review (7) Windows Features (4) XBox Music (2) SBS 2008 All Editions (4) MDOP (2) Microsoft Desktop Optimization Pack (2) Software Assurance (2) W2012E (6) Windows Server 2012 Essentials (6) Internet Explorer (3) USB 3.0 (2) USB Hard Drive (2) Bug Report (2) Microsoft Office 365 (5) sharepoint online (2) BitLocker (2) Windows (2) Microsoft Update (3) Swing Migration (2) Windows Update (4) Outlook (2) Group Policy (9) WS2012e (2) WSUS (3) Office (3) Microsoft Downloads (5) Microsoft Office (3) DRP (3) Virtual Machines (2) Virtual Server Hardware (2) online course (1) SQL Server learning (7) 2 Factor Authentication (2) 2FA (2) PASS Summit 2013 (4) SQLPASS (5) Contest (1) e-learning (1) Udemy (1) smbtechfest (1) backups (2) PASS Summit First Timers (3) IIS (2) RD Gateway (4) RD RemoteApp (2) RDWeb (4) Remote Desktop Connection (2) Remote Web Access (2) Remote Web Workplace (2) Cryptolocker (6) Backup (4) Restore (2) CryptoLocker (1) AuthAnvil (1) SBS 2003 (1) SBS Migration (1) Windows Server 2012 R2 (9) Documentation (1) IE 11 (4) testimonials (11) SQL Server 2008 (1) Best Practices (1) Support (1) Intel Xeon Processor (1) RemoteApp (1) Android (1) iOS (1) Hyper-V Replica (2) PowerShell (2) SBS (3) Break (1) Business Intelligence (1) Excel 2013 (1) Power Map (1) Power Query (1) PowerBI (1) MultiPoint (2) Surface (1) Net Neutrality (1) Opinion (2) ASP (9) HP (2) Scale-Out File Server (8) SOFS (10) Windows Phone (1) Updates (1) Intel NUC (1) Intuit (1) QuickBooks (1) Office364 (1) Intel Server Systems;Hyper-V (1) Firewall (1) Patching (1) Mobile (1) Mobility (1) sharepoint (1) Microsoft Security (1) Beta (1) Storage Replication (1) outlook (1) Hyper-V Setup (3) JBOD (1) Azure (1) PCI (1) PCI DSS (1) PII (1) POS (1) MicroStaff (2) Catherine Barr (2) Third Tier (1) BeTheCloud (1) BrainExplosion (1) LookAWhale (1) Manuel (1) Rayanne (3) SuperSecretNews (1) TechYourBooks (3) Managed Services (1) Training (1) E-mail (1)
RSS Feed
News
Dec
18
Repeat After Me: SATA Does Not Belong In Servers Part Deux
Posted by Philip Elder on 18 December 2013 04:57 PM

Original Post Here:   MPECS Inc. Blog: Repeat After Me: SATA Does Not Belong In Servers Part Deux

NOTE to SMB Kitchen Subscribers: This is the article I was hunting for during our Hyper-V Q&A session yesterday.

For the last number of years we have stopped deploying servers with SATA drives installed.

There are so many reasons why we stopped but here are a few comparisons to SCSI/SAS:

  • SATA does not have the ability to manage a high I/O workload
  • SATA only offers a single inbound and outbound data port while SAS offers dual ports for redundant paths
  • SATA does not have the health monitoring capabilities with SMART certainly not cutting it
  • SATA does not offer anywhere near the capabilities and command set that SAS does for server related tasks, disk redundancy, disk sharing, and so much more

There is a reason why disk manufacturers have tacked on SAS controllers to SATA platter sets. These so-called NearLine drives offer all of the SAS goodness but with SATA capacities.

Here is the first public, that I know of, presentation from Microsoft on the _why_ SATA does not belong in servers.

To quote specifically:

1.Use the per I/O control mechanism that is known as Force Unit Access (FUA). This flag specifies that the drive should write the data to stable media storage before signaling (sic) is finished. Applications that have to do this make sure that data is stable on the disk issue FUA to make sure that data is not lost if a power failure occurs.

Server-class disk drives (SCSI and Fibre Channel) generally support the FUA flag. On commodity drives (ATA, SATA, and USB), FUA might not be honored. (emphasis added) This can potentially leave data in an inconsistent state unless the drive’s write cache is disabled. Make sure that the disk subsystem handles FUA correctly if you depend on this mechanism

When listening to a discussion on this the above applies even when SATA disks are used in a properly configured RAID setup whether software (host-based) or hardware RAID on Chip.

In addition, if one were to be setting up a Storage Spaces cluster with multiple paths to the JBOD unit then one would be required to set it up with SAS based SSDs for the high performance storage tier. SATA will work in a single server and single enclosure lab like setting but _not_ in production.

We have had other posts on this topic that outline many other reasons for our decision to drop SATA in servers. The SATA category and the SAS category would be one place to start. :)

Philip Elder
Microsoft MVP
MPECS Inc.
Co-Author: SBS 2008 Blueprint Book

Chef de partie in the SMBKitchen
Find out more at
Third Tier: Enterprise Solutions for Small Business


Comments (0)
Post a new comment
 
 
Full Name:
Email:
Comments:
CAPTCHA Verification 
 
Please enter the text you see in the image into the textbox below. This is required to prevent automated registrations and form submissions.

Help Desk Software by Kayako Fusion